Passionate disagreement on matters of importance are a sign of healthy community

By Luther College President Jenifer K. Ward and Luther College President-elect Brad Chamberlain

Dear Editor,

Luther College hosted over 150 business owners and citizens of Decorah on campus the last week in January for the 34th annual celebration of our relationship with the Decorah Area Chamber of Commerce and the bestowing of the second Excellence in Collaboration award. It was a reminder of how grounded Luther is in the Decorah community and how significant our employee base is. When a recent vote asked citizens to consider whether they should support the funding for a new elementary school, we urged our neighbors to educate themselves on the issue and to exercise their vote.

Another consequential vote is ahead of us on March 4, 2025. Luther College supports the Decorah City Council’s decision to schedule a second referendum about whether Decorah should establish a municipal electric utility. The first referendum was held on May 1, 2018, and failed by a narrow margin. Iowa law requires communities to wait at least four years before holding a second referendum; the Decorah City Council has waited almost seven years.

Luther College, as an entity, will not have a vote in the referendum, but Luther College will have a great deal at stake as one of the largest purchasers of electricity in the area. Our constituents represent both supporters of continuing the relationship with Alliant Energy and supporters of establishing a municipal electric utility. Regardless of the provider, though, the cost of providing electricity to our campus contributes to the cost of attendance for our students, and so Luther has an understandable interest in learning more about the two paths before us.

We understand that a positive referendum outcome will be the first step in what could become a long process without a predetermined outcome, giving the city the legal standing it has determined it needs to request and receive the information that will aid it in determining the financial feasibility of running a municipal electric utility. This finding will further allow the city to analyze whether an MEU meets the needs of our community, Luther College included. We understand that a negative referendum outcome would signal broad community support for Alliant Energy and the service that it provides to Decorah.

To learn more about the referendum, here is a link to a page on the city of Decorah’s website about establishing a Decorah Municipal Electric Utility: https:/ www.decorahia.org/decorah-meu/education.

To learn more about Alliant Energy’s stance, here is a link to Alliant Energy’s page opposing Decorah’s municipalization referendum: https://www.alliantenergy.com/content-pages/decorah.

We encourage all members of the Luther community and all citizens of Decorah to educate themselves on the referendum and to exercise their civic duty to vote on March 4. Moreover, as we remind students throughout their four years at Luther, passionate and civil disagreement about matters of importance is the sign of a healthy community, not an ailing one. In this matter, too, we hope that principled disagreements are a sign of a community focused upon its improvement – that in the end, we see even in disagreements signs of unity rather than division.

Thank you for your consideration,

Submit A Comment

Fill out the form to submit a comment. All comments require approval by our staff before it is displayed on the website.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments