Christian nationalism – be careful what you wish for

By Lyle Luzum, Decorah

Are you tempted by the idea of turning the U.S. into a “Christian” nation to control all the “sin” you see around you? Do you wish everyone was as Christian as you? Do you resent having to “tolerate” diversity in our liberal democracy and long for a theocracy to enforce Christian values? Well, be careful what you wish for. Look around the world to nations that are run by religions. Is a “Christian” version of them a model you long for? Do you think that wouldn’t happen in your “Christian” USA?

OK, say that dream happened. Whose version of Christian would be in charge? Yours, of course. But wait. Your version of Christian is a small to tiny minority. Christians don’t actually agree on much policy-wise. It doesn’t matter which brand you adhere to, to say nothing of all the non-Christians in the U.S. Here’s a breakdown, according to the Pew Research Center a few years ago (www.pewresearch.org/religion/religious-landscape-study).

Christian: 70.6 percent 

(Looks promising to you? Look further – no one can claim the “Christian” brand belongs to them)

Evangelical Protestant (25.4 percent – in 50 different flavors)

Mainline Protestant (14.7 percent – in 22 different denominations)

Historically Black Protestant (6.5 percent – in 16 different varieties)

Catholic (20.8 percent)

Mormon (1.6 percent – two versions)

Orthodox Christian (.05 percent – four versions)

Jehovah’s Witness (0.8 percent)

Other Christian (0.4 percent – four versions)

Non-Christian: 5.9 percent

Jewish (1.9 percent)

Muslim (0.9 percent)

Buddhist (0.7 percent)

Hindu (0.7 percent)

Other World Religions (0.3 percent)

Other Faiths (1.5 percent)

(Note: All of the above non-Christian have many sub-flavors, not separately identified)

Unaffiliated (religious “nones”): 22.8 percent

Atheist (3.1 percent)

Agnostic (4.0 percent)

Nothing in particular: 15.8 percent

Don’t know: 0.6 percent

If there is anything that distinguishes religions, it is that they are all “right.” Which means everyone else is either uninformed, wrong or evil – good material to righteously smite. History does not bode well for religious rule, regardless of the religion.

Submit A Comment

Fill out the form to submit a comment. All comments require approval by our staff before it is displayed on the website.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments